A visit from a Montana Nazi

The flap started when a 24-year-old Butte man, Shawn Stuart, filed for a state legislature seat as a Republican. The Montana Human Rights Network revealed that he was a member of the American Nazi Party, and the GOP quickly disowned him, even vowed to campaign against him, which means supporting the Democrat in the race.

Pogie Jason has a post up about how the Nazis started harassing the Montana Human Rights Network, Travis McAdam of the Montana Human Rights Network has an editorial in yesterday’s Billings Gazette about the group, and David at Billings Blog has a statement from National Socialist spokesman, Bill White, that claims the GOP originally “encouraged” Stuart to run for the Butte seat.

I riffed off of the Billings Blog post in a “Links…” post and said (rather unfairly? you decide!) “Personally I’m not surprised about which party a Nazi feels comfortable in.”

Guess who submitted a comment to my site? Montana Nazi, Bill White! He pasted a long “press release” to the comments section, most of which I won’t reproduce here, because I don’t want people to waste their mornings wiping down their computer screens. (To read the whole thing, follow the above link to the comments.) But there were a couple of interesting tidbits I hadn’t seen before.

When I lived in Montgomery County, Maryland, I managed the campaign of Constitution Party candidate Brian Saunders. He ran for Congress in Maryland’s 8th District against Democrat Terry Lierman and Republican Connie Morella. The race was tight, and both parties poured money into the campaign. Lierman spent $2 million; Connie spent $1 million. We spent $40,000.

At the end of the day, Brian won 2.6% of the vote. Connie got something like 49% Lierman got some like 48%. The Republicans took notice.

In 2002 I was invited to the Republican Party’s Lincoln Day Dinner. Connie was running again and Democratic State Senator Christopher Van Hollen and State Rep Mark Shriver were vying to oppose her. The Republicans wanted to talk to me.

So I had dinner with Connie, now Maryland Governor Bob Ehrlich, Karl Rove, and most of the local Montgomery County Republican officials.

Connie Morella told me to stop running candidates against her to he right. I told her that I, and the coalition I had built, would not endorse a candidate who was anti-gun, pro-abortion and pro-war. Her response was:

“But if you keep doing this I’m going to lose and a Democrat is going to win.”

I told her:

“I’d rather have an honest scumbag Democrat in office then a dishonest Republican.”

One of the Republican consultants then chimed in:

“But Bill, you don’t understand. It doesn’t matter what the candidates think about the issues. All that matters is that they have an ‘R’ by their name. You see, someone who is pro-gun and anti-abortion can’t survive in this District. But on important party issues she can have the occassional break and vote with the GOP.”

I found that logic extremely offensive. By the end of the night, we had not reached a deal.

A few thoughts:

First, I acknowledge that the source is unreliable, at best. But the conversation seems realistic enough. Even through White’s twisted prism, you can feel the caution and wariness in the tone of the mainstream politicians when dealing with the Nazi, just like you’d imagine in a meeting like this. So it seems somewhat accurate.

Bill White, Nazi, was at a dinner meeting with Karl Rove! Who else would have loved to be a fly on the wall?

It’s interesting that GOP officials wanted White’s candidate to drop out of the race, because he was stealing votes from the Republican Party. That is, the Republicans needed the Nazi vote to win. You make your own snark.

And lastly, let me say that I don’t believe for a second that the Republican Party supports the Nazi ideology in any way, shape, or form. Yes, I’m surprised that Rove and other GOP leaders would even talk to this guy, let alone dine with him, but I understand that it was politics: they were worried this guy would steal a few votes from the far right-end of the spectrum, votes that would otherwise go to Republican candidates, and they needed to talk him from running his candidate. (Still…these people want to vote for Nazis! I say, let them!)

I do think Karl Ohs’ response was the right thing to do. He completely denied any association with the National Socialist party and reaffirmed his party’s “commitment to equal rights and equality for every citizen regardless of gender, age, race, national origin, religion, creed, or physical impairment” (tho’ he left out “sexual orientation”!). Yes, having a Nazi running under your banner is bad publicity, but I do believe that this was one of the rare cases where political expediency met genuine feeling.

So, let’s celebrate this brief moment of togetherness and brotherhood, we liberals and conservatives, as we join hands and agree to dislike Nazis. No pasarán!

About these ads

  1. Well…that’s what the Nazi says. You be the judge!

  2. There sure is a big difference between the National Socialist Party and the World Socialist Party.

    Maybe the Nationals took the name to prevent the Worldwide workers Socialist Party from gaining any traction in this little game of democratic representation?

  3. Yikes! This post is getting some serious attention — and getting distorted along the way! I’ll be curious to see where this goes…

  4. First, not sure I’d trust anything Bill White says… clearly off his rocker.

    Second, it’s unlikely in my mind that Rove was this deeply involved in the primary map of a US congressional seat… He may have been at the event (I’ll have to check the daily planner), but I find it hard to believe that he would have the time given the other political strategeries he was involved in, to have this conversation.

    Third, Rove didn’t choose Bill White to be campaign manager of Brian Saunders, candidate from the Constitution Party. Nor did anyone in the GOP… I can’t find a record of White as campaign manager for Saunders, but I haven’t done an exhaustive search. And if Connie wanted to discourage the candidacy of someone in the Constitution party (which is clearly to the right of the GOP) or the Libertarian party for that matter, they would contact the campaign manager.

    Finally, the whole conversation seems unreal and intended to inflate Bill’s ego… with Bill White playing the principled campaign manager and standing up to the “Jewish-controlled” Republican Party establishment. This is consistent with rants by Bill on his nutjob website.

    But, hey… feel free to connect any dots that you like. But you might want to be cautious before taking anything Billybob “Double-Digit-IQ” White has to say seriously.

    Regards
    St Wendeler
    Another Rovian Conspiracy

  5. Adam Waxman

    This seems very fishy to me. On several levels. First, White could not have been a Nazi at the time he met with the Rs, a meeting I doubt actually took place.

  6. Hell, as mentioned in the post, I was pretty cautious about trusting the source. And I certainly give the GOP the benefit of the doubt. I think the post has been getting packaged to highlight White’s claim he met with Rove…

    Thanks for dropping by.

  7. I think you hit the nail on the head when you said “Personally I’m not surprised about which party a Nazi feels comfortable in.”

    For all the failings of the democrats, I can’t imagine a Nazi even considering teaming up with them.

  8. I understand why some would be surprised that Rove was involved in a meeting for a Congressional race. Morella’s race was a huge target in ’02, though, and the Maryland Governor’s race was as well. It’s not surprising that someone of Rove’s acumen would lend his talents at least briefly for this race.

  9. Ooops. Somehow more got copied into that post than I intended. Don’t know how to edit. Sorry.

  10. Yeah, that was pretty long. Why don’t you just post a list of links? That’ll do. If anyone wants to check them out, they can do so.

  11. PS – People are very interested in your association with Karl Rove. Do you speak with him? Can you give us any evidence that you met with him? Give us the dirt!

  12. Rabbit

    I think that Nazis will be the master race

  1. 1 Oliver Willis » Just Chattin’?

    [...] Karl Rove and other Republican officials invited a Nazi to talk about strategy? What the hell. [...]

  2. 2 4&20 blackbirds » Blog Archive » Everybody loves a Montana Nazi, especially if Karl Rove is involved

    [...] On Friday, I posted a chunk of the comment left by National Socialist, Bill White, on my website. According to White, he attended a dinner with Karl Rove. It was never mentioned how large the dinner was, how serious White’s participation was, and no conversation between Rove and White was mentioned. Still, it was interesting, and I posted on it with a couple of snarks levied against the GOP, but with the conclusion that even the Republican party finds Nazi ideology reprehensible. [...]

  3. 3 4&20 blackbirds » Blog Archive » Denowh reiterates opposition to Butte Nazi; is that enough?

    [...] You’ll recall the brouhaha about Shawn Stuart’s filing as a Republican in a Butte state legislature race, and all the concern expressed by Montana’s GOP, even going as far as saying they would “work to defeat” Stuart. [...]




Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


  • Pages

  • Recent Comments

    problembear on Serious Ethical Questions Surr…
    jhwygirl on Serious Ethical Questions Surr…
    Kirsten Pabst, Misso… on Serious Ethical Questions Surr…
    problembear on Serious Ethical Questions Surr…
    lizard19 on Serious Ethical Questions Surr…
    problembear on Serious Ethical Questions Surr…
    Big Swede on Will War in Ukraine Lead to a…
  • Recent Posts

  • Blog Stats

    • 1,473,889 hits
  • Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    Join 2,199 other followers

  • April 2006
    S M T W T F S
    « Mar   May »
     1
    2345678
    9101112131415
    16171819202122
    23242526272829
    30  
  • Categories


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 2,199 other followers

%d bloggers like this: