Happy B-Day America!

by lizard

What does it mean to aspire? Here is one definition: direct one’s hopes or ambitions toward achieving something.

Words like aspire come in handy when invoking the soaring platitudes of patriotism (platitude: a remark or statement, especially one with a moral content, that has been used too often to be interesting or thoughtful) and what can be more patriotic than America’s b-day, the 4th of July?

Don Pogreba has crafted a patriotic post for America’s b-day to counter the liberals hate America meme, and the title of this patriotic post is Liberals Can Love the United States, Too: A Message for Independence Day . But before getting to aspirational platitudes, the initial framing is, of course, smug partisanship:

I’m never going to enjoy a Toby Keith song about America, nor demand that my neighbors “love or leave” this country. It’s unlikely that I will ever refer to an American media outlet as traitorous, or demand that we build a fenced wall between the United States and Mexico. I don’t believe that, this, or any country has been chosen by a higher power to lead the world, and I don’t believe that the United Nations is using bike lanes as part of a global plot to strip the U.S. of its sovereignty. I do, however, love the United States.

So, after salting the field, how about some of that aspirational stuff:

I love America for what it aspires to be, and what is has the potential to become. The foundation of what this nation celebrates today, the Declaration of Independence, was more than a statement of revolution; it was a statement that governments exist to secure the rights of their citizens, and not to enrich and empower the few. That aspiration has been an inspiration for countless people, revolutionaries and dreamers, and a model for governments around the world for over 200 years.

I love America for its incredible diversity, for its commitment to the idea that our unmatched military might should be used for good, not dominance, its belief that every man and woman should have the opportunity to achieve his/her dreams, and its incredible optimism. I love America for its sense of community, its belief in civil rights and equality, and its capacity to be united.

Our government no longer exists (if it ever did) to secure the rights of its citizens. And our government is no longer a model (if it ever was) for governments around the world. As for this alleged capacity to be united? Well, considering how this post started, forgive me for not being able to suspend my disbelief.

Next, we are told that, alas, despite America’s best intentions, sometimes America deviates from its aspirational origins:

And yet, we fall so short of some of those aspirations. Our government, like any human institution, often falls short of the aspirations that guide it, and sometimes even deliberately does wrong. With all of our power and all of our wealth, we sometimes fail to do what is in the best interest of the world, or even our own citizens. As someone who loves his country, I cannot be silent when I believe we are on the wrong course. I cannot acquiesce when the government oversteps its power, or when it ignores its responsibility to the people it serves.

Using the possessive pronoun “our” when referring to America’s power and wealth is aspirational bordering on delusional. The power and wealth that has essentially destroyed American Democracy is transnational. Of course acknowledging that would undermine the colloquial notion of government this post relies on. Anyway, on to the next platitude:

Liberal criticism of our nation’s policies is often mistaken or mischaracterized by the Right as hatred of America, or a desire to leave. Nothing could be further from the truth. We criticize the government because we believe it can be better, do more, and infringe less. Blind devotion to one’s country is not patriotism; it is nothing more than subservience that Jefferson would have despised.

I agree, blind devotion to one’s country is not patriotism. Now, for a conclusion, how about a disingenuous call for working together?

The celebration of our independence isn’t limited to one side of the political spectrum. Patriotism isn’t about whose flag is flown higher or whose lapel pin is shinier; it’s about working together to make our nation what Jefferson and the other founders hoped it could be, an inspiration for the rest of the world:

The energy, the faith, the devotion which we bring to this endeavor will light our country and all who serve it, and the glow from that fire can truly light the world.

Have a wonderful fourth.

Despite Don’s assertion at the beginning of the post—I don’t believe that, this, or any country has been chosen by a higher power to lead the world—the quote he selects, that America can truly light the world, smacks of Manifest Destiny, or divine selection.

Americans need to get over themselves. The non-American world will not continue accepting our arrogance. That “unmatched military” Don refers to, patriotically of course, actually is matched by counter-forces increasingly putting US foreign policy in check.

So, as people enjoy this three day weekend celebrating American Independence by blowing shit up, terrorizing pets and combat vets, remember, the platitudes of American exceptionalism are skeletal and suffering osteoporosis.

Enjoy the 4th!


  1. A Big Fan

    This certainly wasn’t predictable. You might want to do some serious reflection on the word “smug,” though.

    • lizard19

      don’t be silly, big fan, this post was inevitable ;)

      • A Big Fan

        You might also want to look up Manifest Destiny. I know it’s in the Smug Radicals Handbook, but you might want to read the footnotes next time.

        • lizard19

          all I know is Indians would never have been able to transform this proud nation into the beauty it is today.

          • Big Swede

            Kennewick people had that chance but they were slaughtered.

  2. steve kelly

    A good time to take stock. What is the condition of our “more perfect union?” How are those hard fought first 10 Amendments faring after over two Centuries of wear and tear? How about our soverignty, do we dare check the foundation? Not this time? Well, maybe next year.

  3. So given the reply to Pogie here and the post at the top, I am to assume that liberals *do* hate America?

    (Relax, that’s a joke at least for my part. Every mythology has its dis-reason. As you, possibly inadvertently, pointed out, the ones to be concerned with are those that seek to take down others to bolster belief in the one true mythology.)

    • lizard19

      honestly, I don’t even know what the hell a liberal is anymore.

      • To be blunt, I don’t think anyone does anymore.

        According to every ‘test’ I’ve ever taken attempting to quantify left or right, I am a bleeding heart socialist liberal. The more environmentally minded ‘lefties’ around these parts consider me a loathsome neo-con favoring corporate apologist. I call myself a moderate, but realize that is a tactical and strategic stance, not a ‘belief’ or mythology. For that, I am a Clinton loving ‘neo-liberal’ Democrat apologist. I find most people who self-describe as liberals to either be solid party Democrats, like Norma or Pogie, or else they are revolutionaries/extremists, expecting others to join the cause, fund it, staff it, “fight” for it (a significant word), and lead it, while they will happily talk about it while others do the heavy lifting … and dying.

        Here’s what I ‘believe’ (or in my parlance and mythology, the things that are inarguably beneficial.) I am a democrat, notice the small “d”. We all have reached a singularity where we either sink or swim together. Thus, I hold that a one-world democratic government is not just preferable, but rather a species necessity. We have morphed into a parasite that can destroy its ability to feed off its host. Saving wolves, or wilderness or elephants or rhinos really doesn’t matter if we let honey-bees go extinct. Still, that call isn’t up to the ‘chosen few’ who will lawsuit until their eyes turn gray to get what they want. It isn’t up to a country, unless you love that country so dearly that you delude yourself into thinking a) that no one loves it as much as you, and b) that you can save the species by dictating to the people of one state or one country.

        I “believe” that health care is an inalienable right, and should be universal. I believe that labor is an inalienable power and should be protected by right against capitalists. I ‘believe’ that the most sociopathic and destructive inclusion in the Constitution was the second amendment, and that the most undervalued amendment is the 10th. I ‘believe’ that most ‘conservatives’ aren’t conservative, they are religious regressionists, talibangenicals, and that the finest question ever asked was “Where is your God now?” I ‘believe’ that Imperialism will likely be the death of us all, save that I am likely too old to reap the sowing and thank Dog for it.

        So, am I a liberal? What the hell is a liberal anymore? A revolutionary? An extremist? Buthurt progressives? I don’t have a clue, and most others don’t either.




Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


  • Pages

  • Recent Comments

    Jon Tester’s G… on Senator Tester Backs Wall Stre…
    Digging Deeper: Exam… on A visit from a Montana Na…
    Washing Ton on A New Shelter for Vets or an E…
    Manitou springs on The Dark Side of Colorado
    C. Willie on American Poets: Robinson …
    C. Willie on American Poets: Robinson …
    bretagnebk on The Dark Side of Colorado
  • Recent Posts

  • Blog Stats

    • 1,636,055 hits
  • Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    Join 2,732 other followers

  • July 2014
    S M T W T F S
    « Jun   Aug »
     12345
    6789101112
    13141516171819
    20212223242526
    2728293031  
  • Categories


%d bloggers like this: